Bridge of sighs and a shameful collective catalogue of failure


lemmie Watkins used to have a 10-minute stroll to high school throughout Hammersmith Bridge. Since September, it has grow to be a 40-minute bike journey through Barnes Bridge on roads affected by dashing drivers and riverside paths that flood when the Thames rises.

On winter nights, even adults keep away from her unlit route dwelling throughout Dukes Meadows, a hang-out of muggers and doggers. On Wednesday the 13-year-old slipped and fell crossing a moist Barnes bridge, chopping herself and ruining her college skirt. “It’s actually annoying,” she stated. “If it floods it’s a lot longer within the rain. It’s not good.”

The incapability to reopen the bridge has made London a laughing inventory. Politicians blame one another whereas residents despair. Ms Anderson describes it as an “worldwide embarrassment”. It has even made the New York Times.


On September 9 final 12 months, Transport Secretary Grant Shapps, accompanied by Tory mayoral candidate Shaun Bailey, visited the bridge. In a video, Mr Shapps vowed to “take management” and “get it fastened and reopened”.

Mr Shapps established a taskforce headed by junior transport minister Baroness Vere. Yesterday it met for the fifteenth time. The taskforce contains representatives from Transport for London and Heidi Alexander, Sadiq Khan’s deputy mayor for transport. But Mr Khan stated this week that the taskforce had been little greater than a “speaking store to kick the can down the highway”.

Clemmie’s mom, Julia Watkins, a member of the Hammersmith Bridge SOS residents’ group, agrees. “You can’t stroll over a taskforce,” she stated. “They have achieved nothing. They had been meant to be knocking heads collectively. Baroness Vere factors the finger at Hammersmith and Fulham council. The council factors the finger at Grant Shapps.”

Coronavirus – Mon Dec 21, 2020 / PA Wire

A resident survey discovered some feeling suicidal as a result of of the closure. Almost 9 in 10 stated they’d suffered worse psychological well being. The apolitical Hammersmith Society, in a letter to the Prime Minister, stated: “The communities on either side of the river are unified of their anger, their disappointment and their despair.” There is a rising acknowledgement that solely the Government has the monetary would possibly to interrupt the impasse. The council owns the bridge however can’t afford the £141  million restoration invoice. Mr Shapps desires the council to pay half the invoice. TfL has supplied about £20 million for investigations and design work, together with £4 million for a short-term ferry and repairs from a authorities Covid bail-out final 12 months.

“The Government ought to be capable to break this impasse,” Ms Watkins stated. “They might have straightaway funded a short-term pedestrian and biking bridge. Instead they went for this ludicrous ferry. It’s fully insufficient.”

Mr Bailey, as half of his mayoral marketing campaign, visited the bridge on Thursday. His battle bus pulled up in Barnes, on the south facet of the river. Unfortunately for him, his supporters had gathered on the north facet of the bridge, in Hammersmith.

Even the ferry has been delayed. An preliminary plan was to have it begin working final autumn. Uber Boat by Thames Clippers has received the contract however two short-term piers have but to be constructed. Residents concern providers might not begin till November. “Our contract is to have it operating by the start of October, however we’re in negotiations with TfL to speed up that,” stated a spokesman for Beckett Rankine, which is able to design the piers. “TfL would love it prepared firstly of September, however there are a lot of issues that need to go proper. Normally it might take a 12 months to construct a new pier.”

The bridge has been closed for 2 years / Getty Images

The contract between TfL and Thames Clippers is for a minimal of 12 months, to a most of 5 years. Adults will likely be charged £1.55 per crossing, although youngsters will journey free. There will likely be two ferries, with a third as back-up. The crossing will take 90 seconds, with a boat each 5 to seven minutes in peak hours. “It will likely be a large enchancment for the residents,” the Beckett Rankine spokesman stated. “It will likely be a very slick service. Thames Clippers know what they’re doing.” The supply added: “It’s a lot cheaper than a short-term bridge.”

The council’s most popular possibility is a “double decker” bridge. Designed by architects Foster + Partners and specialist bridge engineers COWI, it might value about £100 million — £41 million lower than absolutely restoring the present bridge. This might permit the bridge to reopen to pedestrians and cyclists in summer season subsequent 12 months, and to drivers two months later — 4 years sooner than in any other case deliberate. But motorists would face an estimated £3 toll.

The different hope for a “fast win” rests with engineers who’ve analysed the structural integrity of the pedestals. It would be the case that the ironwork has stabilised and the bridge could possibly be secure to reopen to pedestrians and cyclists.

The engineers’ report was submitted to the DfT three weeks in the past. But sources say that “additional engineering evaluation and checks must be accomplished” — and this might take a additional three months. Behind the scenes there’s concern about security. The Government desires the council to retain legal responsibility ought to something go improper. Residents are livid on the thought that a “risk-averse tradition” could possibly be used as an excuse to maintain the bridge closed to retain it as a political soccer.

“On that foundation, politicians ought to shut each bridge within the nation,” one stated, noting that youngsters proceed to climb the railings to cross the bridge at evening and use it as a skateboard park. “If they proceed to do this after the engineers’ report exhibits it’s secure, that’s simply despicable. They’re ruining folks’s lives.”

Another resident stated: “If you wish to eradicate danger, it’s a very excessive bar to satisfy.”

As summer season approaches, residents say the longer days make the scenario virtually tolerable. The third lockdown post-Christmas introduced reduction too, as faculties had been closed.

The key date is when the clocks return in October, when the 1000’s a day who observe Clemmie’s route danger being stranded on the improper facet of the river.

Michelle Coulter, one other member of Hammersmith Bridge SOS, whose daughters Iris, 16, and Lana, 13, additionally attend college in Hammersmith, stated youngsters had been typically unable to board the alternative buses. Under Covid guidelines, the single-deckers can solely carry 11 passengers. “Since August it’s grow to be so annoying, I can’t let you know,” she stated. “My youngest finishes college at 4pm. In winter she was getting dwelling at 5.30pm, typically 6pm. That was by bus.”

Her elder daughter takes the prepare to Richmond, and then travels again in on the Tube to Hammersmith. It additionally impacts the ladies’ after-school golf equipment and weekend actions.

“We have checked out presumably transferring home however that’s vastly costly, and home costs are affected by the bridge closure,” Ms Coulter stated.

“It’s actually laborious watching children endure and seeing there’s not sufficient political will to do one thing about it. There is a lot of frustration that the Government have arrange this taskforce, with Grant Shapps saying they will knock heads collectively, however 9 months later no progress has been made.

“The focus is on the North of England. I feel London they’ve written off as a misplaced trigger.”

Mr Khan accuses the Government of “dither and delay” and failing to honour guarantees made earlier than the 2019 General Election.

“Until the Government steps in and provides the monetary assist that the council wants, the bridge received’t reopen to autos,” he admits. TfL’s personal funds have been wrecked by covid and it doesn’t have the money – or the authorized authority – to rebuild the bridge itself.

Mr Khan believes the bridge’s listed standing prohibits the unconventional answer of knocking it down and rebuilding a trendy alternative. Nor does he assist constructing a short-term highway bridge alongside, noting this may require the demolition of properties on either side of the river.

“It’s actually essential that the bridge is reopened as quickly as attainable to pedestrians and cyclists, so I’m very a lot in favour of the bridge reopening in no matter type it may safely for pedestrians and cyclists whereas the work is completed to remediate the bridge so it may reopen for autos, whether or not it’s single decker buses or different autos,” he instructed the Standard this week.

The council submitted its double-decker bridge proposal in February, however it’s regarded by the DfT to be missing element. Two weeks in the past, minister Rachel Maclean accused the council of carrying “gold-tinted lenses” and stated a “clean cheque” wouldn’t be forthcoming. The DfT stated it couldn’t remark as a result of pre-election purdah restrictions.

What London’s mayoral candidates say on fiasco

Sadiq Khan (Lab)

Keen to have the bridge reopened to pedestrians and cyclists if engineers discover the construction secure however says the bridge will solely absolutely reopen to autos when the Government covers the majority of the price. A TfL-funded ferry service is because of begin within the autumn.

Shaun Bailey (Con)

Promises to make the ferry free, construct a short-term highway bridge and absolutely restore the present bridge, which he would rename the Prince Philip bridge. Says it’s important the bridge can carry autos and wouldn’t impose a toll on motorists. Says TfL ought to have funded the total repairs as quickly because the bridge closed in 2019. He would fund his concepts by establishing a TfL funding fund.

Sian Berry (Green)

Believes the Department for Transport ought to present “not less than the bulk of the prices” of repairing the bridge, and desires a date to be set for the reopening of the bridge for strolling and biking.

Luisa Porritt (Lib Dem)

“The Government is the one physique with the funds to foot the invoice. The mayor might make a greater contribution if the £2 billion Silvertown Tunnel highway venture was axed.”

Recommended For You