Labour’s lost heartlands. Can it win them back?

Amanda Milling, co-chair of the Conservative get together, is posing for the photographer exterior The Pot House, a pub on Hartlepool’s scenic Headland peninsula. It’s a stunning day within the north-eastern coastal city: below a cloudless sky, there’s a gorgeous sea view previous the native marina, taking within the factories of Teesside and past to an array of wind generators off the coast close to Redcar.

But issues listed below are much less idyllic than they give the impression of being. Hartlepool, a once-thriving metal city and industrial port that served the close by Durham coalfield, was not too long ago named the tenth most disadvantaged city in England. Its unemployment charge is among the highest within the nation. Even on this picturesque spot, flats change fingers for £30,000, a fraction of what they fetch in Newcastle-upon-Tyne, simply 25 miles away.

If Milling seems shocked to be right here, it’s not solely as a result of she’s simply walked previous a useless rat on the pavement. Time was that Tory politicians had been skinny on the bottom right here — least of all senior ones. “This has been such a Labour stronghold that 20 years in the past we might not even be having this dialog — it could be very extraordinary,” she says.

Since the seat was created in 1974, Hartlepool has by no means elected an MP who isn’t Labour. A ­earlier incumbent was Peter Mandelson — Tony Blair’s shut adviser and a ­galvanising determine in New Labour — who, as ­Milling factors out, received 61 per cent of the vote in 1997, the 12 months Blair swept to energy.

Conservative get together co-chair Amanda Milling on the marketing campaign path in Hartlepool final month: ‘This has been such a Labour stronghold that 20 years in the past we might not even be having this dialog’ © Benjamin McMahon

Yet within the final basic election, the place Labour haemorrhaged 60 seats — largely to the Tories — the get together’s majority right here was slashed to fewer than 4,000 votes.

Tory strategists deemed the seat “simply too far out of our attain” in 2019. But following the resignation of Labour MP Mike Hill, triggering a by-election, Hartlepool is now up for grabs. If Milling and her Conservative colleagues succeed on May 6 — amid a wider set of native elections — the outcome will reveal the extent to which Boris Johnson’s get together has reinvented itself as a house for blue-­collar staff by shattering the nation’s previously impregnable “crimson wall” of Labour strongholds throughout the north of England.

The prime minister received’t be the one get together chief watching the election outcomes keenly subsequent week. If the Tories do lastly triumph in Hartlepool, it will signify a extreme setback for Keir Starmer, who took over as Labour chief a 12 months in the past and has prioritised profitable again these crimson wall voters lost to the Tories. Holding on to the seat would signify a morale increase for Labour. “If we win, it would show that it’s nonetheless value combating for the crimson wall, that every one is just not lost,” says one campaigner in Hartlepool.

A man walking by a wall in Hartlepool

The get together’s historic hyperlinks with organised labour as soon as made it impregnable within the north-east. In the Nineties, the get together didn’t even trouble to do any inside polling in crimson wall areas as a result of it felt so assured of its voters there © Benjamin McMahon

The Hartlepool by-election can also be a bellwether for the largest points which have consumed the UK in years. Has Brexit “been and gone”, as Jim McMahon, the MP operating the Labour marketing campaign, argues? Labour has taken a threat by selecting Paul Williams, an area GP however an outspoken Remainer, as its candidate in a constituency the place practically 70 per cent of individuals voted to depart the EU. 

The race will even be a gauge of whether or not the general public have forgiven Johnson for early missteps within the dealing with of the Covid-19 disaster, or whether or not the success of the vaccine rollout throughout Britain is now foremost in voters’ minds.

What is for certain is that Labour is on a knife-edge on this a part of the north-east. The get together now controls simply six of 30 seats on the native council, which is at the moment dominated by councillors not aligned to both of the principle events. The robust presence of councillors from fringe teams — the Socialist Labour get together, Hartlepool Independent Union, Hartlepool People, Veterans and People’s get together — displays a way of independence that’s nearly distinctive to the city. Labour clung on in 2019 partly as a result of the Brexit get together break up Eurosceptic assist by seizing 11,000 votes. This time the Brexit get together is just not standing.

Milling stays cautious about Conservative possibilities: “This by-election goes to be actually powerful for us,” she says. But the Tories are at the moment the bookies’ favourites to win.

Labour has lost 4 basic elections in a row: two years in the past it was eviscerated below its final chief Jeremy Corbyn, hero of the get together’s leftwing. Starmer was Corbyn’s shadow Brexit secretary, a task wherein he engineered the get together’s backing for a second referendum. That choice, together with Corbyn’s “unpatriotic” world view, has been blamed for the revolt by voters in ­conventional Labour seats.

However, Starmer was by no means a real “Corbynista”. In April 2020 he received the management by providing to maintain a lot of the Corbyn financial agenda and taking part in up his previous as a radical younger lawyer. At the identical time, he indicated that he might be a extra acceptable prospect for swing voters and former Labour supporters in its northern and Midlands heartlands. On a go to to Hartlepool final week, he admitted, “We’re combating for each vote.”

Labour remains to be in style in prosperous cities akin to London, Bristol and Manchester, the place a few of its MPs sit on big majorities. Sadiq Khan, the Labour mayor of London, is anticipated to stride again into workplace on May 6 with ease. But if the get together needs to regain nationwide energy, it wants to succeed in past these metropolitan, liberal strongholds.

Weekend: How Labour’s Red Wall crumbled,. Animated gif

In the north-east of England, it is tough to magnify the extent to which Labour’s fortunes have collapsed. Its historic hyperlinks with organised labour as soon as made it impregnable. In the Nineties, the get together didn’t even trouble to do any inside polling in crimson wall areas as a result of it felt so assured of its voters there. Now Sedgefield in Durham — the place former prime minister Tony Blair as soon as had a majority of 25,000 — is in Tory fingers.

In Hartlepool, Thelma Walker, a leftwing former Labour MP from the Lancastrian constituency of Colne Valley, is standing towards Labour for the Northern Independence get together. Gazing out throughout the North Sea from a bench subsequent to The Pot House pub, she accuses Starmer of over-reliance on focus teams in his bid to win again the voters lost over current elections.

Former Labour Thelma Walker, smiling

Thelma Walker, a former native Labour MP, is combating this by-election on behalf of the Northern Independence get together. She accuses Labour chief Keir Starmer of ‘imitating the Tory message . . .  I feel it’s insulting to northern voters’ © Benjamin McMahon

“It’s not a imaginative and prescient or a perception from the guts that you would be able to make the world a greater place for ­everybody,” she says. More than that, he’s “imitating the Tory message . . . I feel it’s insulting to northern voters.”

At first, voters gave the impression to be responding to Starmer. After changing into chief in April 2020, because the coronavirus disaster gripped the nation, he managed to dent the polling hole between Labour and the Conservatives, quickly lowering it from 20 factors to nearly zero by November.

He additionally eliminated the exhausting left from the shadow cupboard, expelling those that refused to just accept his uncompromising crackdown on anti-Semitism. That included Corbyn himself, who now sits as an unbiased following his unceremonious ejection from the get together. In these internecine battles he has been ruthless. “None of us anticipated it to be a counter-revolution towards Corbynism, however that’s what it is,” says one leftwing MP.

But in current weeks, with Johnson basking within the glory of his authorities’s vaccination scheme, the Tories have raced forward once more. Polls counsel that Starmer, together with his severe, lawyerly method, is seen as a reputable leader-in-waiting, regardless of missing showman qualities. But is that sufficient?

One Labour determine worries that Starmer is perceived as a “managerial” and “cautious” determine. “The downside he’s acquired is that there was a second in early 2020 when individuals checked out Keir with some curiosity — they observed that he wasn’t Jeremy Corbyn — however past that they didn’t know a lot about him and so they nonetheless don’t actually know,” she says.

A desolate house in Hartlepool

A once-thriving metal city and port, Hartlepool was not too long ago named the tenth most disadvantaged city in England, and at the moment has one of many highest unemployment charges within the nation © Benjamin McMahon

The pandemic has reduce each methods, too. With MPs working largely from dwelling and restrictions on campaigning, Starmer has struggled to rebuild a demoralised political operation remotely. “It is troublesome campaigning with out the same old buzz of lots of of individuals leafleting,” says McMahon.

Out and about in Hartlepool, locals are having fun with the April sunshine on the Headland, dwelling to the city’s historic district. Sitting close to the Heugh Battery — an previous coastal defence — one pensioner says she’ll vote Labour on May 6 “as a result of that’s what my mam and pop instructed me”. But that perspective, which sustained the get together within the heartlands for many years, is beginning to disappear.

Stuart Allison, an outsourcing employee, is passing the rock swimming pools when he stops to talk. He says he doesn’t know the way he’ll vote on polling day. Asked about Starmer he says, “He’s pale, isn’t he?” — too bland for his tastes. Robin Carter, a 75-year-old former seaman, won’t be voting for the get together. To him, the Labour chief appears to face each methods: “He says one factor in a single place and one thing else in one other.”

Robin Carter, a retired seaman from Hartlepool, looking at the camera

Former seaman Robin Carter won’t be voting Labour. To him, get together chief Keir Starmer appears to face each methods: ‘He says one factor in a single place and one thing else in one other’ © Benjamin McMahon

Others complain about Starmer’s makes an attempt to tack in direction of the centre, reviving recollections of New Labour, when many established members of the get together felt disenfranchised by a perceived ­metropolitan elite.

Phil, a public-sector employee, says of Starmer: “I’d like to know what he actually believes. He’s taking a stance which isn’t central sufficient to transform Tories however he’s alienated the left as nicely. It might be a catastrophe for him.”

In his bid to revive Labour’s electoral prospects, Starmer should stroll a tightrope. On the one hand, he’s being urged by Labour’s youthful activist base to pursue radical, ever-more progressive insurance policies. On the opposite, he has to cope with what’s seen because the extra conservative mindset of the get together’s conventional working-class base in locations like Hartlepool.

For now, he has largely ignored the issues of leftwingers akin to Walker and adopted the map plotted out by Blair a era in the past, wrapping himself within the Union Jack, promising fiscal ­self-discipline and paying homage to the royal household and the British navy. His chief of workers, Morgan McSweeney, is an ally of Mandelson, the previous Hartlepool MP.

There are different snares, too. Brexit might have lastly occurred, however the tradition struggle it unleashed remains to be raging. While ostensibly about EU membership, the referendum created an identification divide between the Remain and Leave camps that has redrawn the British political map and break up the general public down the center between “progressive” and “small-c conservative” strains.

A family playing on the Headland peninsula in Hartlepool

Tory strategists deemed Hartlepool ‘simply too far out of attain’ in 2019. But with PM Boris Johnson rising within the polls on the again of the Covid vaccine roll-out, the Conservatives at the moment are the bookies’ favorite to win the seat on May 6 © Benjamin McMahon

Starmer’s dilemma has been painfully evident on events over the previous 12 months. On points such because the royals and the removing of historic statues, he has generally appeared stranded between radical Labour members, who’re pushed by their need for social justice, and public consensus, which is extra hesitant on these issues.

“Voters are extremely patriotic and supportive of the armed forces, it’s one thing they’re actually, actually happy with,” says Milling, the Tory chair. “When Keir Starmer talks about this it appears fairly superficial — while you get under the floor it appears very face-value. I’m unsure if he believes it.”

Along the way in which, this divide additionally helped break up Labour’s historic coalition. Younger, extra internationalist graduates dwelling in cities tended to vote to remain within the EU. Others who felt “left behind” — typically dwelling in distant cities with erratic transport hyperlinks, sub-par housing and poor job prospects — voted for Brexit. That included big numbers of former Labour voters who had been sad that the get together’s management backed Remain.

“Everything detonated round Brexit however Brexit was symptomatic of a longer-term development,” says Jon Cruddas, the MP for Dagenham, a working-class space in east London that voted overwhelmingly to depart the EU and that Labour solely narrowly held on to in 2019.

Cruddas was a key determine within the “Blue Labour” motion which, a decade in the past, urged the get together’s management to hear extra intently to blue-collar issues about immigration, crime and the EU. In his new ebook, The Dignity of Labour, he argues that his get together is at risk of changing into dominated by “the meritocratic elite” moderately than blue-collar staff.

A cluster of houses in Hartlepool

Relying on younger and concrete votes won’t be sufficient to revive Labour’s fortunes warns MP and writer Jon Cruddas: he says the get together should sort out ‘long-term, structural points’ to win once more in England © Benjamin McMahon

“Some say there was a pure reordering and that Labour has a brand new base of assist amongst youthful, city voters in college cities and [that with] this alignment, by way of demographic change, we’ll be on the precise facet of it,” says Cruddas. “Whereas I feel these are long-term structural issues [and] that if we don’t right them, we received’t win once more in England.”

He backs Starmer’s try and “construct bridges throughout this divide” however says it is tough to do given “this factor has festered for 20 years”.

Mandelson dismisses the notion that Labour didn’t do sufficient for northern cities whereas in energy, however acknowledges that it was unable to fight the decline of the previous heavy industries that used to maintain many such cities. “In Hartlepool, I keep in mind the announcement of a brand new name centre being celebrated. But a name centre is just not a substitute for a serious manufacturing facility, a rising port or a thriving metal works,” he tells the Financial Times.

The disappearance of previous industries created a vacuum in lots of crimson wall areas. New types of employment — typically present in distribution hubs and retail depots — have disconnected communities and fostered unhappiness with the political institution. “I’m afraid we didn’t crack this nut and nor has any authorities since, regardless of our Herculean efforts,” says Mandelson.

Meanwhile, seats akin to Great Grimsby, Blyth Valley and Leigh have turned blue for the primary time for the reason that second world struggle. Boris Johnson’s authorities is promising to “degree up” struggling areas by channelling extra taxpayer cash in direction of infrastructure tasks in crimson wall seats and shifting 1000’s of civil servants out of London. What critics describe as “boosterism” from Johnson is seen as positivity by many blue-collar staff in former Labour areas.

In Tees Valley, a area that features Hartlepool, the locals are anticipated to re-elect Tory mayor Ben Houchen after a March Budget filled with new cash for Teesside. “You’d suppose they had been giving everybody a free home and 20 grand in an envelope, persons are so determined to have some hope and a few perception,” says one native Labour determine. “People right here have felt hammered for therefore lengthy, they need to imagine issues are getting higher.”

Hartlepool council leader Shane Moore with some election leaflets

Shane Moore, the chief of Hartlepool council, says the success of Tees Valley mayor Ben Houchen in securing new funding for the realm will even see individuals who ‘aren’t Tory and haven’t voted Tory say they’ll vote Tory now’ © Benjamin McMahon

Shane Moore, an unbiased councillor who’s now chief of Hartlepool council, says there was a “Ben Houchen” impact within the space. “Love the Tories or hate them, while you converse to individuals who aren’t Tory and haven’t voted Tory earlier than many say they’ll vote Tory now as a result of… he’s like Santa Claus, he will get cash delivered for giant shiny tasks. And greater than something, he talks the realm up moderately than speaking it down.”

Along with its many different results, the pandemic has scrambled the same old guidelines of politics.

At first, Starmer sought to look an ally of the federal government, however a important one, a place with echoes of the way in which Labour MPs served in Winston Churchill’s wartime cupboard. Increasingly, nevertheless, he turned important of blunders and missteps by Tory ministers, akin to delayed lockdowns and the awarding of private protecting tools contracts to buddies. “We’ve been criticised from either side — for being a constructive opposition, and for not being supportive sufficient,” says one senior member of the shadow cupboard.

Indeed, regardless of 127,000 deaths and an financial implosion, the general public has been surprisingly tolerant of the federal government’s dealing with of the disaster. “People had been fairly sympathetic . . . It was a brand new virus, no person knew something about it,” says Milling. One member of the shadow cupboard agrees: “People see it as one thing like an earthquake, the place it’s not anybody’s fault.”

Now, argues Peter Hayes, senior lecturer in politics at Sunderland college, as lockdown eases and life begins trying extra regular for hundreds of thousands of individuals, the Tories will profit from a post-­pandemic euphoria. “If you return six months, you had Starmer saying we must always lock down longer and tougher, which caught the general public temper,” he says. “But now Boris Johnson has pulled this wonderful rabbit out of the hat by shopping for hundreds of thousands of vaccines which prove to work.”

Labour MP Jim McMahon, looking at the camera

The Hartlepool by-election can also be a bellwether for the largest points which have consumed the UK in years. But Jim McMahon, the MP operating the Labour marketing campaign, believes Brexit “been and gone” © Benjamin McMahon

Moore, the Hartlepool council chief, says that voters don’t need to discuss final 12 months’s travails. McMahon agrees: “Everyone desires to get again to normality and spend time with their family members.” At some level sooner or later the general public will likely be prepared for a ­dialog about what went flawed, he provides — simply not now.

The relentless deal with the pandemic has additionally sucked oxygen from Starmer’s makes an attempt to redefine Labour and set out his different imaginative and prescient of the long run. Before Covid-19 hit, he was anticipated to chart a path between Corbyn’s financial radicalism and the Tories. But Johnson and his chancellor, Rishi Sunak, have deserted any pretence at fiscal self-discipline throughout the pandemic, spending an eye-watering £407bn on their emergency response.

According to former Labour chancellor Alistair Darling, the size of Johnson’s spending makes it exhausting for Starmer to distinguish himself on fiscal grounds. “No one is fascinated by a spending dividing line in the intervening time,” he says. “Not when the quantity being spent is way past the creativeness of most individuals.”

In a digital speech in February, Starmer tried to flesh out a longer-term imaginative and prescient, promising to “elevate our sights” in direction of the last decade forward. To the alarm of colleagues on the get together’s left he made a acutely aware pivot away from Corbyn’s high-tax, high-spending concepts, vowing to make a advantage of monetary duty. At the identical time, he promised a extra interventionist authorities of the kind that Labour chief Clement Attlee drew up after the second world struggle. Ideas included a splurge in housebuilding, extra motion to sort out local weather change and motion to enhance care houses.

But one shadow cupboard member says it is simply too early for detailed policymaking: “The public don’t need to hear our nice concepts proper now for future coverage . . . till we come out of the opposite facet [of the pandemic].”

A streetscape in Hartlepool

Former Labour chief Neil Kinnock thinks it will ‘very, very, very troublesome’ for Labour to win again crimson wall voters by 2024: ‘Come the referendum, extra individuals went towards Labour. And as soon as they’ve carried out that when, it’s simpler to do it once more’ © Benjamin McMahon

Labour analysts are poring over the teachings from the postwar interval, when Churchill, having led the nation triumphantly by way of a disaster, lost the next election to Attlee, who provided a transformative new welfare state.

It’s a concept that appears moderately optimistic. In the WhatsApp teams of Westminster, Starmer’s identify is at the moment extra typically in comparison with that of one other Labour chief who spent years easing the get together out of its leftwing rut and again to a place of electability. Neil Kinnock did not make it to Downing Street within the 1987 and 1992 elections, however paved the way in which for Tony Blair’s landslide 5 years later. Does the person himself suppose Starmer is ­destined for a similar destiny?

Chatting in a north London park, Kinnock mulls over the comparisons being made with Starmer.

“I feel it is extra Attlee than Kinnock,” he says, whereas promptly admitting that the comparability solely goes up to now: “Attlee had three or 4 years wherein to reveal his trustworthiness as a frontrunner in authorities. Keir goes to should do it with out getting that.”

Kinnock says he knew the 2019 election could be a catastrophe. “You solely needed to knock on any 10 doorways, particularly in Labour seats, to know the breadth and depth of the antagonism in direction of Corbyn and what individuals thought Labour had change into.”

Describing the “appalling disappointment” of dropping the crimson wall seats, the previous chief acknowledges it goes to be “very, very, very troublesome” for Starmer to win again the lost voters earlier than 2024, when the subsequent election is due. But he sees Labour’s disastrous 2019 outcome as an “lively rejection” of Labour’s standing below Corbyn moderately than “any lively assist for ­Johnson’s Tories”. Labour, he says, must forge new bonds with these voters who’ve abandoned the get together for the reason that 2016 referendum.

A Union Jack flying in a semi-derelict area of Hartlepool

British voters are ‘extremely patriotic, it’s one thing they’re actually, actually happy with,’ says Tory co-chair Milling. ‘When Keir Starmer talks about this it appears fairly superficial’ © Benjamin McMahon

“The downside was, for plenty of Labour voters, it was the primary time they went towards their historic household ties — , time and time once more you hear, ‘I voted Labour, my granddad voted Labour, he could be delivering his grave.’ But come the ­referendum, extra individuals went towards Labour. And as soon as they’ve carried out that when, it’s simpler to do it once more.”

In Starmer’s defence, Kinnock thinks the risky political temper of the nation post-coronavirus performs to his successor’s strengths of “maturity, steadfastness and solidity”.

However, one other get together veteran warns: “I concern that if Starmer begins falling again then the left will say, ‘He can’t win elections both, we have to change into extra radical once more’, and we enter a everlasting cycle.”

Hartlepudlians are each pleasant to outsiders and likewise sceptical of them. Mandelson — one among many southern New Labour MPs who had been parachuted into secure northern seats — remembers with amusement what a woman out there mentioned to him when he first stood in 1992. “Don’t let anybody let you know that you would be able to’t win as a result of you aren’t from the city. Your predecessor wasn’t from these components both — he got here from Easington [down the road in Durham].”

Some locals say Jill Mortimer, the Tory candidate, is from North Yorkshire as if the adjoining county had been midway to the moon. Nor do they like the truth that Williams was MP for Stockton South, a mere eight miles away. “We’re at all times ­getting outsiders imposed on us,” says one pensioner.

During two visits to Hartlepool within the by-­election marketing campaign, Starmer has emphasised how Williams, the Labour candidate, is a physician who labored within the native hospital throughout the pandemic. There remains to be public anger concerning the closure of the accident and emergency companies at Hartlepool Hospital in 2011 — below a Tory-led coalition. Yet there was little signal of a Keir Factor driving any renewed curiosity within the Labour get together.

None of the locals chatting with the Financial Times spontaneously raised the allegations of cronyism and sleaze which Labour is attempting to weaponise towards the federal government.

A shot of the North Sea from the Headland peninsula

‘We are on the arse finish of the world, only a sprawling housing property. We don’t actually make something any extra,’ says one loyal Labour voter in Hartlepool © Benjamin McMahon

Mandelson says such points won’t on their very own win elections for Labour. “I’ve been on doorsteps speaking to my former voters; what struck me . . . was that they didn’t count on something higher,” he says. “They don’t have excessive expectations of Boris or of politicians as an entire.”

Glenda Griffin, a 56-year previous store employee, who has voted Labour up to now however supported the Brexit get together in 2019, says she’s heard tales on the radio about Tory sleaze however says: “I don’t fairly know what to make of it, a method or one other.”

She is contemplating whether or not to again the Tories. “When I used to be rising up we had been at all times instructed, vote for Labour, they’ll stick up for you, they’re our get together, the get together of the working lessons,” she says. Then we had Brexit and I realised they weren’t on my facet . . . At least the Tories did Brexit.”

There are nonetheless 1000’s of loyal Labour voters within the city too, together with Gillian, a public-sector employee who says that every one leftwingers ought to fall behind the Labour get together to forestall Britain changing into a “one-party nation” with the Tories ceaselessly in cost. “Covid has carried out us no favours, Keir has needed to facet with the federal government on Covid at occasions, that has made individuals suppose he’s weak,” she says. “I don’t suppose he’s weak in any respect.”

All the discuss new cash for Teesside overlooks the truth that the Tories have been in energy for greater than 10 years, she says. Where was the funding then? Looking out to sea from the Headland, on Hartlepool’s heritage coast, she gives her ideas in town’s future. “We are on the arse finish of the world, only a sprawling housing property. We don’t actually make something any extra.” 

Jim Pickard is the FT’s chief political correspondent. Sebastian Payne is the FT’s Whitehall editor

Follow @FTMag on Twitter to seek out out about our newest tales first.

Recommended For You